Copy Her Look—This "Dated" Makeup Trend Will Rule Fall 2025

Jenna Ortega’s Nostalgic, Rockstar-Chic Makeup Look for the Fall Season

Jenna Ortega has been making waves in the fashion and beauty world since her breakout role as Wednesday Addams on Netflix. As the second season of the show approaches, Ortega continues to embrace a gothic, cool girl aesthetic that resonates with fans and fashion enthusiasts alike. Recently, she made an appearance at a New York City fan screening, where her red carpet look was nothing short of iconic.

The star arrived in a leather-and-lace Ann Demeulemeester gown, which perfectly complemented her signature rockstar-chic style. What truly stood out, however, was her makeup—a nostalgic nod to early 2000s trends that have been reimagined for a modern audience. This Y2K-inspired look, featuring fully rimmed eyeliner and cool-toned concealer lips, is making a strong comeback, especially among A-listers like Julia Fox and Billie Eilish.

Ortega's makeup artist, Lilly Keys, played a key role in crafting this look. She kept the eye makeup simple to balance out the star's bleached brows, allowing the smoky eyeliner to take center stage. The complexion was equally pared back, with a sculpting bronze applied to the cheekbones and brow bones. A cool-toned, nude-pink lip added the final touch, giving the overall look a fresh, modern twist.

This fall, many are looking to recreate Ortega’s style, and there are several products that can help achieve this effect. Here are some must-have items:

Chanel Les Beiges Healthy Glow Natural Eyeshadow Palette in Medium

This eyeshadow palette is a perfect match for Ortega’s moody eye look. It includes cool-toned brown, gray, and taupe shades, along with a light base and a metallic silvery white. Using the ivory base as a primer, blend the taupe and brown shadows into the inner and outer corners of the eyes, and use the metallic shade for a pop of shimmer on the center of the lids.

Victoria Beckham Beauty Satin Kajal Eyeliner in Black

This kajal liner is ideal for achieving that smoky, vampy look. Its creamy formula is easy to blend and forgiving, making it perfect for creating sharp, defined lines. The classic black color will give you a look that’s true to Ortega’s style, while the shimmer-flecked Night Flash version adds a touch of elegance for evening events.

E.l.f. Cosmetics Halo Glow Skin Tint SPF 50

This skin tint offers a natural, glowy finish that’s perfect for a minimalist makeup look. Its sheer coverage blurs pores while providing hydration and protection. It’s an excellent choice for those who want to keep their skin looking fresh and radiant without heavy makeup.

Makeup by Mario Ultra Suede Sculpting Lip Pencil in Smokey Pink

This lip pencil is a favorite among celebrities for its ability to define and plump the lips. The gray-pink shade makes it easy to create a fuller, more defined look, and it pairs well with a concealer lipstick for a believable, natural finish.

MAC M·A·Cximal Silky Matte Lipstick in Acting Natural

This lipstick offers a velvety matte finish with a hint of shine, making it ideal for Ortega’s dusty-pink pout. It provides long-lasting wear and hydration, and can be applied either across the lips or just on the center for added dimension.

Additional Products to Elevate Your Fall Makeup Look

For those looking to expand their makeup collection, here are a few more products inspired by Ortega’s style:

• NATASHA DENONA Mini Xenon Eyeshadow Palette – Offers a range of cool-toned shades perfect for creating depth and dimension.
• E.l.f. Cosmetics Cream Glide Lip Liner in Truth or Bare – Provides a smooth, long-lasting line that complements any lip color.
• Maybelline Color Sensational Lipstick in Nude Lust – A versatile nude pink that works well for both day and night.
• Revlon Colorstay Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil in Black – Ensures your eyeliner stays in place all day.
• Laura Mercier Tinted Moisturizer Light Revealer Natural Skin Illuminator SPF 25 – Adds a subtle glow while protecting the skin from UV damage.

With these products, you can easily recreate Jenna Ortega’s nostalgic yet modern makeup look for the fall season. Whether you're heading to a red carpet event or just want to feel confident in your own skin, these items are sure to elevate your beauty routine.