Elon Musk Faces Police Backlash Over Controversial Tesla Claim: 'It Is Still Illegal'

Elon Musk, the CEO of Tesla, has once again found himself in a situation that has drawn criticism from law enforcement. This time, it's due to his casual remarks about what drivers can do while using Tesla's Supervised Full Self-Driving (FSD) technology.

What's happening?

According to reports, Musk made some concerning comments on the social media platform X. He suggested that drivers using FSD might be able to text on their phones "depending on the context of surrounding traffic." This statement immediately raised concerns among observers and law enforcement officials.

The issue is that Tesla's FSD is not considered a fully autonomous system. Drivers are still required to remain attentive and ready to take control at any moment. Law enforcement agencies in several states have confirmed that texting and driving remains illegal, even when using advanced driver-assistance systems. The only exceptions are for emergencies, such as calling 911.

"In all other cases, texting and driving/talking (while holding a phone) is still illegal," stated a spokesperson for the Arizona Department of Public Safety, as reported by Business Insider.

Despite the inconvenience for Musk and drivers who are eager for fully autonomous driving, Tesla's system includes the word "Supervised" for a reason. The technology is currently under legal challenges and investigations by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) due to frequent traffic violations, such as running red lights.

Why are Musk's misleading comments about FSD important?

Musk's inaccurate statements continue a pattern of overstating the progress of Tesla's FSD technology. If drivers take his words at face value, it could lead to increased risks for other drivers and pedestrians.

Business Insider noted that some drivers, like Ring CEO Jamie Simonoff, are already taking liberties with FSD and finding ways to bypass its alerts about not paying attention. These alerts are meant to protect drivers, but many see them as a nuisance rather than a safety feature.

Autonomous driving holds significant potential. In theory, if the technology reaches a certain level, it could lead to safer roads with fewer incidents of human error and road rage. However, despite some positive developments, there are enough issues with FSD to suggest that it is not yet reliable.

Beyond the individual accidents that could result, these controversies could harm the future of autonomous driving. Given Tesla's prominent position in the market, negative perceptions could also impact the broader autonomous driving industry, including companies like Waymo.

Would you buy a self-driving car?

• Absolutely!
• Depends on the cost
• Not anytime soon
• Nope!

Click your choice to see results and speak your mind.

What's being done about Musk's irresponsible claims?

Law enforcement has the final say on what is legal and what is not — not Musk. If drivers choose to text and drive, they will have to rely on the discretion of police officers not to issue traffic tickets. Simonoff mentioned that he has had mixed experiences with this.

Meanwhile, if more accidents occur due to inattentive drivers, Tesla's FSD will face even more scrutiny from the NHTSA. Bad publicity can be costly, especially in the event of a major accident, which could cost Tesla millions of dollars.

It could be even more expensive if negative headlines dominate the narrative around autonomous driving and hinder its long-term success.

Get TCD's free newsletters for easy tips to save more, waste less, and make smarter choices — and earn up to $5,000 toward clean upgrades in TCD's exclusive Rewards Club.