Musk clashes with EU as regulators side with Washington in US tech crackdown

The Fine Imposed on X by the European Commission

Elon Musk’s social media platform, X, has been fined £120 million ($140 million) for violating the European Union’s Digital Services Act (DSA). This decision comes after a two-year investigation conducted by the European Commission, which found that X was not in compliance with the EU’s digital regulations. The DSA, adopted in 2022, aims to regulate online platforms and ensure they operate transparently and responsibly.

The fine is the first of its kind under the DSA, marking a significant moment in the regulation of digital services within the EU. The European Commission identified three main violations during the investigation:

• Deceptive design of X’s blue checkmark system: Before Musk acquired the platform in 2022, the blue checkmark was reserved for high-profile individuals such as celebrities, politicians, and influential accounts. After the acquisition, the system was changed to allow anyone to pay $8 per month for the badge. Regulators argue this change makes it harder for users to identify authentic accounts, increasing the risk of scams and impersonation fraud.
• Lack of transparency in its advertising repository: The platform was found to be non-transparent about how it manages and displays advertisements, raising concerns about user privacy and data protection.
• Failure to provide access to public data for researchers: X did not grant researchers access to public data, hindering efforts to study the platform’s impact on society.

The fine is divided into three separate penalties: £45 million for the blue checkmark issue, £35 million for the advertising repository problems, and £40 million for blocking researchers from accessing public data.

X now has 60 days to inform the Commission about how it will address the blue checkmark issues and 90 days to submit plans for fixing its advertising repository and researcher access problems. If the company fails to comply, additional periodic penalty payments may be imposed.

U.S. Officials’ Reactions to the Fine

U.S. officials have expressed strong criticism of the EU’s decision, arguing that it targets American companies unfairly. Secretary of State Marco Rubio called the fine an attack on American tech platforms and the American people by foreign governments. Vice President JD Vance accused the European Commission of attempting to penalize X for not engaging in censorship.

Musk initially responded to the fine with a post on X stating that the decision was “bullshit.” However, his reaction escalated over the following days, as he claimed that the EU should be abolished and that sovereignty should be returned to individual countries so their governments can better represent the people.

U.S. Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick recently suggested that the EU must revise its digital regulations to secure a deal for reducing its steel and aluminum tariffs. The Trump administration has consistently argued that the EU unfairly targets U.S. technology companies with severe financial penalties and burdensome regulations.

The U.S. Ambassador to the EU, Andrew Puzder, stated that the fine, which was placed not just on X but also on Musk himself, is an example of regulatory overreach targeting American innovation. However, European officials have denied these accusations. A Commission spokesman, Thomas Regnier, emphasized that the EU is not targeting any specific country or company based on its origin. He also noted that the EU prefers to settle cases constructively when companies engage with the Commission, using TikTok as an example.

Additional Regulatory Actions in the EU

In addition to the fine against X, Meta was recently found in breach of EU competition rules over its pay or consent system earlier this year. The company was fined £200 million and is now required to give users a choice between sharing all their data for fully personalized advertising or opting to share less personal data for an experience with more limited personalized advertising.

Get up to $30,050 in trading rewards when you join Bybit today